181
edits
Changes
Talk:Untitled (from Head Like A Hole) (view source)
Revision as of 20:52, 20 February 2011
, 20:52, 20 February 2011no edit summary
We need to think of new title for this fragment instead of ...from HLAH.
Reason: it appears in the end of ''Down in it (demo)'' on UK LE DII (but not as separate track as on HLAH) [[User:BenAkenobi|BenAkenobi]] 06:54, 15 February 2011 (PST)
:Calling it "track 11" etc could be just as confusing, it's an unnamed track and so the page needs to reflect that I feel. Could do a redirect page from both to something ... Also, are you sure? There's not mention of it anywhere else [[User:Sheepdean|sheepdean]] [[User_talk:Sheepdean|Try to speak as clearly as you can]] 07:13, 15 February 2011 (PST)
::i think a simple "clip from early show by Kelly Ripa" is far from confusing... p.s. i am sure, what proof do you require? [[User:BenAkenobi|BenAkenobi]] 07:19, 15 February 2011 (PST)
:::Well, a direct rip from the CD would be useful. Even nincatalog doesn't mention it [[User:Sheepdean|sheepdean]] [[User_talk:Sheepdean|Try to speak as clearly as you can]] 07:51, 15 February 2011 (PST)
::::nincatalog doesn't depict every detail (yet), i could send you the rip but you would say i just merged tracks 10 and 11 from HLAH... here's an idea for solid confirmation - post a question in ets marketplace about it, will you? [[User:BenAkenobi|BenAkenobi]] 08:03, 15 February 2011 (PST)
:i do think it should be renamed ("Dance Party USA" works), but i guess it'd be nice to have someone corroborate that the snippet appears on the Halo 1 UK LE. - [[User:Seasonsinthesky|seasonsinthesky]] 17:03, 15 February 2011 (PST)
::Sorta proof from nincatalog. Here [http://nincatalog.com/trackitem.asp?trackkey=01-00104&tracknumkey=6] you can see length difference (namely 3:57 and 3:52), i can assure you that's where the sample is. [[User:BenAkenobi|BenAkenobi]] 00:29, 19 February 2011 (PST)
:::since i'm not about to go buy/trade for one of these LE DIIs (though someone else may want to in order to corroborate), the only thing that could convince would be making a proper, secure rip of the disc with EAC and providing the log with the files. that's a bit of an infringement, though... but at least the log would prove it's actually the audio on the disc. - [[User:Seasonsinthesky|seasonsinthesky]] 09:49, 19 February 2011 (PST)
::::If it is not a separate track on DII, then on the DII song page it should list under versions the difference, and as the ONLY release that has it as its own track is HLAH, the page name remains correct. No? [[User:Sheepdean|sheepdean]] [[User_talk:Sheepdean|Try to speak as clearly as you can]] 09:07, 20 February 2011 (PST)
:::::Technically/morphologically the page name remains correct, but, given the nature of this clip, i don't feel it really needs its own page. Give it a comment on HLAH page about its legacy instead ("bla-bla-bla bonus to the demo of Down in it bla-bla-bla") without linking anywhere further (because DII article is already linked somewhere in the beginning of HLAH article). Tough? [[User:BenAkenobi|BenAkenobi]] 11:35, 20 February 2011 (PST)
::::::Personally, I think every original track on every NIN release, save silent tracks, should have its own page. This may not be by NIN, but it IS a track that was released under the name. [[User:Sheepdean|sheepdean]] [[User_talk:Sheepdean|Try to speak as clearly as you can]] 12:22, 20 February 2011 (PST)
:::::i'm pretty much in between re: whether or not this page should exist. it doesn't add a lot, but there's not much to add; it's a solitary track on an official halo, but it's not actually by NIN, and seems to be a joke. now that it's here, i don't really see justification for removing it, if only for an OCD sense of completion. - [[User:Seasonsinthesky|seasonsinthesky]] 12:29, 20 February 2011 (PST)
::::::No problem in having a page for the clip simply because it is 11th track, just rename it to something shorter and more...mmm organically reflecting its relation to DII rather than to HLAH... PHM's Schrödinger's Cat ;) [[User:BenAkenobi|BenAkenobi]] 12:45, 20 February 2011 (PST)